All Pies

Choose your pies, select size and place your order for instore pickup or ship to an address. You can also call ahead for pickup at (603) 432-1927 and walk-ins are always welcome. We recommend calling to see what pies we have in stock prior to visiting, as we are selling out daily.

Call Us
  • Classic Chicken Pot Pie
    From $11.95
    From $11.95
    Sold Out
    $11.95
    $11.95
    Sold Out
    View details
  • Short Rib Pot Pie
    From $17.95
    From $17.95
    Sold Out
    $17.95
    $17.95
    Sold Out
    View details
  • Turkey Pot Pie
    From $11.95
    From $11.95
    Sold Out
    $11.95
    $11.95
    Sold Out
    View details
  • Beef Stroganoff Pot Pie
    From $15.95
    From $15.95
    Sold Out
    $15.95
    $15.95
    Sold Out
    View details
  • Chicken Cordon Bleu Pot Pie
    From $15.95
    From $15.95
    Sold Out
    $15.95
    $15.95
    Sold Out
    View details
  • Taco Pot Pie
    From $15.95
    From $15.95
    Sold Out
    $15.95
    $15.95
    Sold Out
    View details
  • Veggie Pot Pie
    From $9.95
    From $9.95
    Sold Out
    $9.95
    $9.95
    Sold Out
    View details
  • Buffalo Chicken Pot Pie
    From $11.95
    From $11.95
    Sold Out
    $11.95
    $11.95
    Sold Out
    View details
  • Lobster Pot Pie
    $46.00
    $46.00
    Sold Out
    $46.00
    $46.00
    Sold Out
    View details
  • Bratwurst Beer and Cheddar Pot Pie
    From $15.95
    From $15.95
    Sold Out
    $15.95
    $15.95
    Sold Out
    View details
  • BBQ Pork Pot Pie
    From $15.95
    From $15.95
    Sold Out
    $15.95
    $15.95
    Sold Out
    View details
  • The Seafood Newburg
    $35.95
    $35.95
    Sold Out
    $35.95
    $35.95
    Sold Out
    View details
  • Bacon Mac’N’Cheese Pot Pie
    From $11.95
    From $11.95
    Sold Out
    $11.95
    $11.95
    Sold Out
    View details
  • Cheeseburger Mac’n’Cheese Pot Pie
    From $14.95
    From $14.95
    Sold Out
    $14.95
    $14.95
    Sold Out
    View details